Phase 4 — Plan first QPU IDCT8 kernel given the M5 32.95us/dispatch
constraint. Frame-level dispatch (8160 WGs for 1080p), 64
invocations/WG = 4 blocks/WG, 3 SSBOs + push constants, reproduces
FFmpeg's transposed column-pass orientation. Predicted M2 ~16 Mblock/s
(BW-limited), R ~ 2.0 -> strong PASS under phase1.md decision rules.
Phase 5 — Second-model review by Claude Sonnet (fresh-context Agent,
no prior session memory). Verdict PASS-WITH-REVISIONS with 2 RED-class
findings + 1 YELLOW that this commit applies:
RED finding 5 (dst race condition): int32_t[] dst with 4 lanes
writing to overlapping 32-bit words = non-atomic concurrent
writes = Vulkan UB. Fix: uint8_t[] via storageBuffer8BitAccess
(verified exposed). Applied to phase4.md sec 5 + GLSL declaration.
RED finding 7 (early-return before barrier): if (block_idx >=
n_blocks) return; ahead of barrier() is UB by Vulkan spec.
For 1080p (32640 blocks, /4) no partial WGs; for any frame
width not /32 there are. Fix: oob flag, gate work bodies,
barrier() unconditional. Applied to phase4.md sec 4 pseudocode.
YELLOW finding 6 (subgroup ops): docs claimed BASIC+VOTE only;
actual exposed set is BASIC+VOTE+BALLOT+SHUFFLE+
SHUFFLE_RELATIVE+QUAD per vulkaninfo. Plan doesn't use any
subgroup ops in v1 so unaffected, but the wrong constraint
would mislead Phase 6/7. Corrected in phase0.md sec 2,
phase2.md sec 6, phase4.md sec 1 (C4).
GREEN/YELLOW findings 1-4, 8 (orientation, WG geom, idle lanes, BW
prediction, compute envelope accounting) accepted as-is or deferred to
Phase 7 M6 sweep per plan's existing flagging.
Reviewer verdict post-revisions: "Phase 4 is APPROVED for Phase 6
implementation. No re-review needed; revisions are mechanical and
address verified bugs/errors."
Phase 5 itself just paid for itself: two real UB bugs caught before
any GLSL was written.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
