chromium-fourier NEXT.md: hit the clang 22 vs 147 wall
build and publish packages / distcc-avahi-aarch64 (push) Successful in 38s
build and publish packages / lmcp-any (push) Successful in 7s
build and publish packages / lmcp-debian (push) Successful in 4s
build and publish packages / claude-his-any (push) Successful in 7s
build and publish packages / ffmpeg-v4l2-request-aarch64 (push) Successful in 11m33s
build and publish packages / claude-his-debian (push) Successful in 5s

First-build summary on chromium-builder@boltzmann. gn gen succeeds
with our V4L2VDA-unlock args. ninja fails immediately on:

1. chromium 147 emits clang flags (-fno-lifetime-dse,
   -fsanitize-ignore-for-ubsan-feature=array-bounds) that clang 22
   doesn't know. Arch Linux ARM is on clang 22; clang 23 hasn't
   landed in extra yet.
2. Bundled x86_64 esbuild is invoked via qemu-x86_64-static but
   /lib64/ld-linux-x86-64.so.2 isn't installed — same shape as the
   bundled node-linux-x64 issue we already fixed by symlinking to
   system node. Smaller wall.

Documents 5 paths forward (grind patches / pin chromium 132 (7Ji's
known-good) / pin 138-141 middle ground / use chromium's bundled
clang / wait for Arch ARM clang 23) with estimated effort and trade-
offs. Recommends pinning to a chromium version that compiles clean
against clang 22 as the fastest path to a working browser, then
bumping as Arch ARM bumps clang.

Build host state preserved — container running, source extracted,
gn-gen'd, no compile artifacts. Easy to resume from any of the five
paths.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
This commit is contained in:
2026-04-26 01:02:24 +00:00
parent 055fc0ba06
commit f3a7b8f1c1
+110
View File
@@ -0,0 +1,110 @@
# chromium-fourier — first-build status (2026-04-26 00:42 UTC)
## Where we are
Build environment: **chromium-builder LXD container on boltzmann**
(8 cores, 28 GB RAM cap, 824 GB NVMe, Beryllium OS rkr3 host kernel).
Source: chromium-147.0.7727.116 release tarball extracted at
`/build/chromium/src` (25 GB extracted).
`gn gen out/Default` **succeeds** with our 7Ji-style args
(`use_v4l2_codec=true use_v4lplugin=true use_linux_v4l2_only=true
use_vaapi=false`, system toolchain via `unbundle:default`, system clang
at `/usr/bin/clang`, version-symlink `/usr/lib/clang/23`
`/usr/lib/clang/22`, compiler-rt-adjust-paths style suffix patch
manually applied). 28057 targets generated.
`ninja -C out/Default chrome` **fails immediately** with two distinct walls:
### Wall 1 — clang version mismatch (chromium 147 ↔ Arch clang 22)
Chromium 147's compile flags include
`-fno-lifetime-dse` and
`-fsanitize-ignore-for-ubsan-feature=array-bounds`. Both are clang 23+
features. Arch Linux ARM ships **clang 22.1.3** (extra repo). Every
single C++ compile fails with `clang++: error: unknown argument`.
Resolutions, in order of effort:
- **(a)** Wait for Arch ARM to bump clang to 23. Tracking package
upstream — happens whenever LLVM 23 lands in extra. Days to weeks.
- **(b)** Use chromium's bundled clang via
`tools/clang/scripts/update.py`. That hits the same CIPD/gs://
"linux-arm64 isn't a first-class target" issue we saw with
`gclient sync` earlier — chromium's clang prebuilts are x86_64-only
for many platforms.
- **(c)** Fork an older chromium (e.g., 132 or 138) that compiles
cleanly with clang 22. 7Ji's chromium-mpp PKGBUILD targets 132 and
builds clean on Arch ARM today. Loses 15 versions of upstream
chromium evolution but ships fast.
- **(d)** Patch chromium 147 to drop the offending flags
(`build/config/compiler/BUILD.gn` has the cflags lists). 50200 line
patch, brittle across version bumps but tractable. Fights every
rebase.
### Wall 2 — bundled x86_64 esbuild under qemu
After Wall 1 (or independently for Action targets):
`qemu-x86_64-static: Could not open '/lib64/ld-linux-x86-64.so.2'`
when chromium runs the bundled x86_64 `esbuild` from
`third_party/devtools-frontend/.../scripts/build/typescript/ts_library.py`.
Same shape as the bundled `node-linux-x64` issue we already fixed (we
symlinked system node into that path). `esbuild` needs the same
treatment — install system esbuild via `npm install -g esbuild` and
symlink it into the path chromium expects. Or install `qemu-user-static`
+ `glibc-x86_64` to make the bundled binary actually run.
**Wall 2 is much smaller than Wall 1** — a handful of bundled-x86_64
binaries to identify and replace, vs. fundamental clang version mismatch.
## What worked
- LXD container provisioning on boltzmann via his recommendation —
the host environment is right.
- Tarball-instead-of-gclient approach — sidesteps CIPD-doesn't-have-
linux-arm64 problem for source acquisition, leaves only a few
bundled binary issues at build time.
- Wall 1 / Wall 2 are both **identifiable and bounded**. We're past
the "is this even doable" phase; this is now down to grinding the
patches.
## Options — needs your call
1. **Grind through Wall 1 with patches** — patch
`build/config/compiler/BUILD.gn` to drop flags clang 22 doesn't
know. Iterate per build error. Estimated 515 patch-and-retry
cycles to compile clean. Then 610 h actual build.
2. **Pin to chromium 132** — match 7Ji's known-working version on
Arch ARM. Drop our STUDY focus on "current upstream Chromium" and
ship a 1-year-old binary. Build should work much sooner.
3. **Pin to chromium 138 or 140** — middle ground. Likely uses clang
22 features and not 23. Some research needed to find the cutover.
4. **Use chromium's bundled clang** — not viable on linux-arm64
without extensive sysroot setup; same CIPD issue as gclient sync.
5. **Wait for Arch ARM clang 23** — passive, days-to-weeks horizon.
Recommended (FWIW): **start with (3)** — find the latest chromium
version that builds clean against clang 22 (probably 138-141 range),
ship that as `chromium-fourier`, then bump as Arch ARM bumps clang.
That gives us a working browser in a few hours rather than days, on
mainline Linux + Wayland + V4L2 unlock — which is the actual goal.
The "current upstream Chromium" requirement was nice-to-have, not
essential.
## State of the build host (preserved)
- Container: `chromium-builder` on boltzmann (running, idle)
- Source: `/build/chromium/src` (extracted tarball, 25 GB)
- Build dir: `/build/chromium/src/out/Default` (gn-gen'd, no artifacts)
- Tools installed: gn, ninja, clang 22, lld, gperf, nodejs (system),
rust, qt5/6, all the gtk/wayland/va/v4l deps from the long pacman
shopping list
- Patches applied to source: `compiler-rt-adjust-paths` style (manual)
- Symlinks: `/usr/lib/clang/23``/usr/lib/clang/22`,
`third_party/node/linux/node-linux-x64/bin/node``/usr/bin/node`
- Service unit history: `chromium-fetch.service` (one-shot, succeeded
on tarball + extract); `chromium-build.service` (one-shot, three
failed attempts above).
Discard the container and start over with option 2 if you pick that
direction; otherwise iterate from current state.